| List Rank | PA Rank | Name | Elevation | Saddle | Prominence | Line Parent | Isolation | Proximate Parent | County | Quadrangle | LiDAR |
| McKean County HP | 2,464' | 2,464' | 0' | Cobb Hill | 13.21 | Lookout Mountain | McKean & Potter | Shinglehouse - Map | |||
| 1 | 59 | Prospect Hill | 2,450' | 1,890' | 560' | Lookout Mountain | 14.53 | Lookout Mountain | McKean | Smethport - Map | |
| 2 | 66 | 2430 | 2,430' | 2,070' | 360' | Prospect Hill | 5.86 | 2450 | McKean | Norwich - Map | |
| 3 | 89 | 2370 | 2,370' | 2,070' | 300' | 2430 | 4.12 | Prospect Hill | McKean | Smethport - Map | |
| Allegheny National Forest HP | 2,370' | 2,370' | 0' | 2373 | 10.21 | 2373 | McKean | Stickney - Map | |||
| 4 | 104 | 2332 | 2,332' | 1,970' | 362' | Cobb Hill | 7.62 | 2464 | McKean & Potter | Shinglehouse - Map | |
| Devils Den | 2,330' | 2,190' | 140' | 2370 | 1.12 | 2370 | McKean | Smethport - Map | |||
| Howard Hill | 2,314' | 2,150' | 164' | Clare Benchmark | 14.63 | Prospect Hill | McKean | Mount Jewett - Map | |||
| 5 | 129 | 2298 | 2,298' | 1,970' | 328' | Prospect Hill | 2.67 | Prospect Hill | McKean | Port Allegany - Map | |
| 6 | 136 | 2290 | 2,290' | 1,950' | 340' | Cobb Hill | 5.34 | 2298 | McKean | Port Allegany - Map | |
| Evans Hill | 2,270' | 2,230' | 40' | Prospect Hill | 5.97 | 2430 | McKean | Norwich - Map | |||
| 7 | 155 | 2263 | 2,263' | 1,930' | 333' | Cobb Hill | 3.92 | 2332 | McKean | Bullis Mills - Map | |
| Dana Heights | 2,245' | 2,230' | 15' | Clare Benchmark | 10.98 | 2302 | McKean | Cyclone - Map | |||
| 8 | 178 | 2230 | 2,230' | 1,830' | 400' | Lookout Mountain | 2.58 | Fox Mountain | McKean | Emporium - Map | |
| Bush Hill | 2,230' | 2,070' | 160' | Prospect Hill | 1.06 | Prospect Hill | McKean | Smethport - Map | |||
| Columbia Hill | 2,230' | 2,090' | 140' | Clare Benchmark | 6.95 | 2298 | McKean | Eldred - Map | |||
| Cherry Hill | 2,210' | 2,150' | 60' | Clare Benchmark | 13.92 | 2302 | McKean | Lewis Run - Map | |||
| Big Shanty Hill | 2,210' | 2,150' | 60' | Clare Benchmark | 12.09 | 2302 | McKean | Lewis Run - Map | |||
| Jay Cox Hill | 2,210' | 2,170' | 40' | Prospect Hill | 5.80 | 2430 | McKean | Crosby - Map | |||
| Swede Hill | 2,130' | 2,010' | 120' | Clare Benchmark | 17.59 | Warren County HP | McKean | Cornplanter Bridge - Map | |||
| Bishops Summit | 2,130' | 2,110' | 20' | 2430 | 10.81 | Prospect Hill | McKean | Hazel Hurst - Map | |||
| Rocky Ridge | 2,110' | 2,070' | 40' | Clare Benchmark | 22.09 | Prospect Hill | McKean | Kane - Map | |||
| 9 | 312 | 2052 | 2,052' | 1,710' | 342' | Prospect Hill | 2.39 | 2298 | McKean | Smethport - Map | |
| Nipple, The | 2,050' | 1,790' | 260' | Prospect Hill | 1.40 | Prospect Hill | McKean | Smethport - Map |