| List Rank | MI Rank | Name | Elevation | Saddle | Prominence | Line Parent | Isolation | Proximate Parent | County | Quadrangle |
| 1 | 120 | Mackinac County HP | 1,005' | 665' | 340' | Chippewa County HP | 29.23 | Chippewa County HP | Mackinac | Pontchartrain Shores - Map |
| Maple Hill | 1,005' | 815' | 190' | Chippewa County HP | 20.06 | Chippewa County HP | Mackinac | Ozark NE - Map | ||
| 2 | 128 | Mackinac Island | 905' | 580' | 325' | Chippewa County HP | 17.91 | 1048 | Mackinac | Round Island - Map |
| Sugar Loaf Rock | 825' | 775' | 50' | Mackinac Island | 0.24 | Mackinac Island | Mackinac | Round Island - Map | ||
| Mackinac Wilderness HP | 825' | 825' | 0' | Chippewa County HP | 13.43 | Mackinac County HP | Mackinac | Ozark SE - Map | ||
| Peek-A-Boo Hill | 745' | 665' | 80' | Mackinac County HP | 9.39 | Mackinac County HP | Mackinac | Hessel - Map | ||
| Castle Rock | 735' | 705' | 30' | Chippewa County HP | 7.03 | Mackinac Island | Mackinac | Evergreen Shores - Map | ||
| Rabbit Back Peak | 725' | 615' | 110' | Chippewa County HP | 6.71 | Mackinac Island | Mackinac | Evergreen Shores - Map | ||
| Round Island | 695' | 580' | 115' | Mackinac Island | 2.08 | Mackinac Island | Mackinac | Round Island - Map | ||
| Horseshoe Bay Wilderness HP | 695' | 695' | 0' | Chippewa County HP | 11.04 | Mackinac Island | Mackinac | Charles - Map |