| List Rank | NJ Rank | Name | Elevation | Saddle | Prominence | Line Parent | Isolation | Proximate Parent | County | Quadrangle |
| 1 | 54 | Second Watchung Mountain | 670' | 330' | 340' | Mine Mountain | 8.98 | High Mountain | Essex | Caldwell - Map |
| First Watchung Mountain | 670' | 410' | 260' | Mine Mountain | 9.54 | High Mountain | Essex | Orange - Map | ||
| Mayapple Hill | 590' | 510' | 80' | Second Watchung Mountain | 5.51 | Second Watchung Mountain | Essex | Caldwell - Map | ||
| Stony Hill | 590' | 570' | 20' | Second Watchung Mountain | 2.43 | Second Watchung Mountain | Essex | Orange - Map | ||
| Riker Hill | 350' | 330' | 20' | Second Watchung Mountain | 3.12 | Second Watchung Mountain | Essex | Caldwell - Map |