| Rank | Peak Name | Elevation | Rise | State |
| 1 | Superstition Peak | 5,051' | 1,842' | AZ |
| 2 | 4986 | 4,986' | 754' | AZ |
| 3 | 4889 | 4,889' | 524' | AZ |
| Flatiron, The | 4,700' | 29' | AZ | |
| "Three Sisters" | 4,414' | 188' | AZ | |
| 4 | 4003 | 4,003' | 573' | AZ |
| "Grandfather Hobgoblin" | 3,570' | 180' | AZ | |
| "Vertigo Spire" | 3,450' | 140' | AZ | |
| "The Mirage" | 3,410' | 80' | AZ | |
| 5 | 3399 | 3,399' | 409' | AZ |
| 6 | Black Top Mesa | 3,354' | 564' | AZ |
| "The Crying Dinosaur" | 3,350' | 100' | AZ | |
| 7 | 3281 | 3,281' | 311' | AZ |
| "The Prong" | 3,270' | 60' | AZ | |
| "The Tower" | 3,170' | 160' | AZ | |
| 8 | 3097 | 3,097' | 467' | AZ |
| 9 | Yellow Peak | 3,061' | 491' | AZ |
| "The Hand" | 3,030' | 140' | AZ | |
| "The Iceberg" | 2,990' | 100' | AZ | |
| Palomino Mountain | 2,930' | 280' | AZ | |
| Black Mesa | 2,850' | 100' | AZ | |
| 10 | "Turk's Cap" | 2,822' | 492' | AZ |
| 11 | 2810 | 2,810' | 360' | AZ |
| 12 | Battleship Mountain | 2,797' | 507' | AZ |
| 13 | Hackberry Mesa | 2,793' | 388' | AZ |
| Red Hills | 2,769' | 239' | AZ | |
| 14 | 2613 | 2,613' | 401' | AZ |
| 15 | 2563 | 2,563' | 333' | AZ |
| 16 | Roadside Benchmark | 2,131' | 330' | AZ |
| Adjacent Quadrangles: | ||
| Stewart Mountain | Mormon Flat Dam | Horse Mesa Dam |
| Apache Junction | Goldfield | Weavers Needle |
| Desert Well | Superstition Mountains SW | Florence Junction |
| Map of peaks in this quad | ||