| Rank | Peak Name | Elevation | Rise | State |
| 1 | Buttes North, The | 5,842' | 462' | AZ |
| 5794 | 5,794' | 294' | AZ | |
| Blue Dog Ridge | 5,740' | 40' | AZ | |
| 2 | Buttes South, The | 5,683' | 343' | AZ |
| 3 | McDonald Mountain | 5,621' | 841' | AZ |
| 4 | 5580 | 5,580' | 440' | AZ |
| 5 | 5407 | 5,407' | 387' | AZ |
| 6 | 5380 | 5,380' | 560' | AZ |
| 7 | 5361 | 5,361' | 501' | AZ |
| 8 | 5318 | 5,318' | 498' | AZ |
| 9 | Cypress Hill | 5,265' | 485' | AZ |
| 10 | 5239 | 5,239' | 339' | AZ |
| 5191 | 5,191' | 291' | AZ | |
| 5143 | 5,143' | 283' | AZ | |
| Agate Mountain | 4,900' | 240' | AZ | |
| 11 | 4665 | 4,665' | 405' | AZ |
| 12 | 4537 | 4,537' | 357' | AZ |
| 13 | 4534 | 4,534' | 394' | AZ |
| 14 | Narrows Peak | 4,501' | 587' | AZ |
| 15 | Wolverton Mountain | 4,494' | 314' | AZ |
| 16 | 4449 | 4,449' | 309' | AZ |
| 17 | 4332 | 4,332' | 352' | AZ |
| Adjacent Quadrangles: | ||
| Payson North | Diamond Point | Promontory Butte |
| Payson South | McDonald Mountain | Diamond Butte |
| Gisela | Sheep Basin Mountain | Buzzard Roost Mesa |
| Map of peaks in this quad | ||