Interesting conversation regarding the name of this peak near Holy Cross:
http://www.summitpost.org/image/60769/152818/looking-northwest-from-the.html
"Mountain Jim" must have an older edition of the Ormes guide than I do in which the peak is called Finnegan Peak. The 10th ed. features no reference to the peak at all. A real estate company appears to be aware of the name. Perhaps it's well-known to locals?