Forum of Lists

Hey All,

Don't know if this has been discussed, but what is SOP on counting a peak twice because one has went over to a second peak and back over the first, assuming both are ranked on the 300 foot rule? Is this two summits in a day, or three? For example, is Redcloud, Sunshine, Redcloud, count for doing Redcloud twice?

For me, not so much. Seems one could find a local 300' hill, run some laps, and up some stats (albeit, lower some others). But I noticed that on the "lists category leaders" some people seem to count this way (am I right here?). Is this even an issue? Does there need to be a standard?

I would say that none of this matters to me, personally, but I'd be lyin'. Hey, this is Lists of John, after all!
Just food for thought, sorry if this has been beat to death somewhere , or if it is a can o' .

tyson ferryman wrote:Seems one could find a local 300' hill, run some laps, and up some stats (albeit, lover some others). But I noticed that on the "lists category leaders" some people seem to count this way (am I right here?). Is this even an issue? Does there need to be a standard?

The Stats Category Leaders only counts a peak once per day regardless of how many same day re-summits are logged.

Thanks, Brian, for that info.
Does this effect any stats, then? Total peaks, 14er repeats, ave. elevation, five summits in a day, etc...?

Peaks are only counted once per day for Total Peaks, Average Elevation, 5+ Peaks in a day, but can be counted multiple times for Most Repeats.

I personally do not list ascents of the same peak more than once in a day (I have gone over the same summit in the same day probably 20 separate occasions). People have the option of adding as many ascents as they like for the same day, but many stats are based on unique peaks in a day. 5+ peak days or any other ascent detail pages will show distinct summits one time only. For example, someone's peak list for the year will show all repeats:
http://listsofjohn.com/PeakStats/ViewDateRange.php?Member=Ken%20Nolan&dm=11&dd=07&dy=2010&dme=11&dde=07&dye=2010
While the ascents detail only credits each summit once per day:
http://listsofjohn.com/PeakStats/ascentsdetail.php?Id=58&M=Ken%20Nolan&D=2010-11-07
Similarly, someone's full year list will show all ascents regardless of how many repeats of the summit take place on the same day (202 ranked peaks for Ken):
http://listsofjohn.com/PeakStats/ViewDateRange.php?Member=Ken%20Nolan&dm=01&dd=01&dy=2010&dme=12&dde=06&dye=2010
But when counting total summits on the leaderboard, these same-day repeats aren't counted:
http://listsofjohn.com/PeakStats/Conten ... .php?r=all (Ken has 190 as of today's date)
In short, the reason for the different methods is: For competition purposes, I do not view reascents of the same summit in the same day to be a fair metric...

Thanks, Brian, and John for the info. I was looking for.

On a side note, someone asked me if using medians or modes would be better for some metrics. Thoughts?