| # | Name | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle | Repeats |
| 1 | High Point | 1,799' | 868' | Sussex | Port Jervis South | |
| 2 | Warren County HP | 1,610' | 700' | Warren | Portland | |
| 3 | Bearfort Mountain | 1,490' | 340' | Passaic | Wawayanda | |
| 4 | Morris County HP | 1,395' | 225' | Morris | Franklin | |
| 5 | 1258 | 1,258' | 328' | Morris | Tranquility | |
| 6 | Bald Mountain | 1,164' | 594' | Bergen | Ramsey | |
| 7 | Pimple Hills | 1,150' | 500' | Sussex | Newton East | |
| 8 | Smith Benchmark | 1,070' | 100' | Hunterdon | Hackettstown | |
| 9 | Fox Hill | 1,035' | 305' | Hunterdon | Califon | |
| 10 | Mine Mountain | 870' | 320' | Somerset | Bernardsville | |
| 11 | Second Watchung Mountain | 670' | 340' | Essex | Caldwell | |
| 12 | Union County HP | 570' | 180' | Union | Chatham | |
| 13 | Baldpate Mountain | 490' | 220' | Mercer | Pennington | |
| 14 | Crawford Hill | 390' | 340' | Monmouth | Keyport | |
| 15 | Riker Hill | 350' | 20' | Essex | Caldwell | |
| 16 | Middlesex County HP | 305' | 75' | Middlesex | Monmouth Junction | |
| 17 | Hudson County HP | 270' | 65' | Hudson | Weehawken | |
| 18 | Burlington County HP | 245' | 160' | Burlington | Columbus | |
| 19 | Ocean County HP | 230' | 87' | Ocean | Cassville | |
| 20 | Berlin Benchmark | 219' | 124' | Camden | Clementon | |
| 21 | Gloucester County HP | 185' | 20' | Gloucester | Pitman East | |
| 22 | Salem County HP | 165' | 30' | Salem | Elmer | |
| 23 | Atlantic County HP | 155' | 50' | Atlantic | Hammonton | |
| 24 | Cumberland County HP | 145' | 20' | Cumberland | Elmer | |
| 25 | Cape May County HP | 65' | 10' | Cape May | Port Elizabeth |