| # | Name | Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Counties | Quadrangle |
| 1 | Todt Hill | 2049 | 415' | 415' | Richmond | The Narrows |
| 2 | Harbor Hill | 365' | 170' | Nassau | Sea Cliff | |
| 3 | Long Hill | 265' | 265' | New York | Central Park | |
| 4 | Queens County HP | 265' | 90' | Queens | Sea Cliff | |
| 5 | Kings County HP | 220' | 135' | Kings | Brooklyn |