| List Rank | Name | NY Rank | Elevation | Prominence | Isolation | County | Quadrangle | Image | Report | YDS Class |
| 1 | Haystack, Mount | 3 | 4,960' | 843' | 1.26 | Essex | Mount Marcy - Map | | ||
| 2 | Skylight, Mount | 4 | 4,924' | 577' | 0.97 | Essex | Mount Marcy - Map | | ||
| 3 | Whiteface Mountain | 5 | 4,865' | 3,110' | 15.91 | Essex | Lake Placid - Map | | ||
| 4 | Dix Mountain | 6 | 4,839' | 2,822' | 5.89 | Essex | Dix Mountain - Map | | ||
| 5 | Basin Mountain | 7 | 4,826' | 807' | 1.27 | Essex | Mount Marcy - Map | | ||
| 6 | Gothics | 8 | 4,734' | 650' | 1.51 | Essex | Keene Valley - Map | | ||
| 7 | Colden, Mount | 9 | 4,714' | 892' | 1.76 | Essex | North Elba - Map | | ||
| 8 | Giant Mountain | 10 | 4,625' | 2,969' | 6.35 | Essex | Rocky Peak Ridge - Map | | ||
| 9 | Nippletop | 11 | 4,609' | 1,378' | 1.56 | Essex | Dix Mountain - Map | |||
| 10 | Santanoni Peak | 12 | 4,606' | 2,425' | 8.33 | Essex | Santanoni Peak - Map | | ||
| 11 | Saddleback Mountain | 13 | 4,527' | 377' | 0.67 | Essex | North Elba - Map | |||
| 12 | Table Top Mountain | 14 | 4,412' | 426' | 1.97 | Essex | North Elba - Map | |||
| 13 | Hough Peak | 15 | 4,409' | 390' | 0.99 | Essex | Dix Mountain - Map | |||
| 14 | Macomb Mountain | 16 | 4,389' | 600' | 1.24 | Essex | Dix Mountain - Map | |||
| 15 | Rocky Peak Ridge | 17 | 4,383' | 627' | 0.88 | Essex | Rocky Peak Ridge - Map | | ||
| 16 | Marshall, Mount | 18 | 4,379' | 525' | 1.68 | Essex | Street Mountain - Map | | ||
| 17 | Allen Mountain | 19 | 4,350' | 660' | 2.03 | Essex | Mount Marcy - Map | |||
| 18 | Seward Mountain | 20 | 4,347' | 2,035' | 6.35 | Franklin | Ampersand Lake - Map | |||
| 19 | Big Slide Mountain | 21 | 4,248' | 1,115' | 3.66 | Essex | Keene Valley - Map | | ||
| 20 | Esther Mountain | 22 | 4,238' | 318' | 1.61 | Essex | Franklin Falls - Map | |||
| 21 | Slide Mountain | 23 | 4,190' | 3,295' | 136.56 | Ulster | Peekamoose Mountain - Map | | | |
| 22 | Lower Wolfjaw Mountain | 24 | 4,173' | 679' | 1.87 | Essex | Keene Valley - Map | | ||
| 23 | Street Mountain | 25 | 4,150' | 1,280' | 3.18 | Essex | Street Mountain - Map | |||
| 24 | Sawteeth | 26 | 4,150' | 492' | 0.98 | Essex | Dix Mountain - Map | | ||
| 25 | Cascade Mountain | 27 | 4,097' | 1,194' | 2.56 | Essex | Keene Valley - Map | | ||
| 26 | Seymour Mountain | 28 | 4,091' | 1,024' | 1.38 | Franklin | Ampersand Lake - Map | |||
| 27 | Colvin, Mount | 29 | 4,084' | 754' | 0.97 | Essex | Dix Mountain - Map | 3 | ||
| 28 | Porter Mountain | 30 | 4,084' | 328' | 0.53 | Essex | Keene Valley - Map | |||
| 29 | Hunter Mountain | 31 | 4,050' | 2,160' | 14.70 | Greene | Hunter - Map | |||
| 30 | East Dix | 32 | 4,005' | 315' | 1.06 | Essex | Dix Mountain - Map |